Mark nice job on this file conversion and posting, I noticed you, Art, and I are linked to Scot’s blog; a kind gesture on his part…I hope we can contribute to the discussions on his blog and continue to have posts worthwhile to read by him.
I’m thinking that at some point after the dust of this all settles, we should “debrief” with all involved and think about how we can keep the “conversation” going….but if I know you you’re already thinking about that!
Can I ask, as someone who wasn’t present, what was it about Scot’s presentation that ruffled feathers? It seemed pretty tame to me. Good stuff - one of the best presentations I’ve read yet on things emerging.
Sorry for the delayed answer; your comment got caught by my spam filter for some reason.
The “behind the scenes” answer to your question (I got this from Scot personally) was that he was a little nervous, assuming that at a conservative Reformed seminary an emergent-friendly Arminian would not be warmly recieved. Because of that, he came on a little strong in his first address. Although I didn’t feel this way, some students felt they were being scolded, which struck them as peculiar since there was so much in his talk that they could resonate with.
I think that as the three days progressed and Scot had opportunity to interact with our students, the vast majority of whom were very welcoming, he warmed up to us, as we did to him. I’m hoping that he left impressed that, whatever doctrinal difference may be there, most of us at WTS share a missional passion with him.
[...] scot mcknight recently delivered some lectures at westminster theological sem, one specifically on “what is the emerging church?”. the transcript of the talk is available (in pdf download) from mark at sacred journey. here’s the link to the pdf. mcknight blogged about the time at wts here. [...]
[...] Mark Traphagen (who blogs at the foolish sage) posted the full text of Scot McKnight's definition which he gave in his first address to the Westminster Theological Seminary Student Association Forum An Eternal Word in an ‘Emerging World’? [...]
[...] Scot McKnight’s talk last weekend at Wesminster Theological Seminary is now available (PDF from Mark at Sacred Journey). You can read Scot’s post on the conference here. [...]
[...] for more information. Here’s an interview. Here is a detailed presentation by McKnight on “What is the emerging church?” Roger asks if I disagree with Mclaren, Driscoll, Padget and Bell overall. I have heard very [...]
[...] the religiously-interested among us. I took the time to print off the thirty-page document found here titled, “What is the Emerging Church?†by Scot McKnight. It is his lecture given eight days ago [...]
October 29th, 2006 at 5:25 pm
Mark nice job on this file conversion and posting, I noticed you, Art, and I are linked to Scot’s blog; a kind gesture on his part…I hope we can contribute to the discussions on his blog and continue to have posts worthwhile to read by him.
Sets
October 29th, 2006 at 5:32 pm
Tony,
I’m thinking that at some point after the dust of this all settles, we should “debrief” with all involved and think about how we can keep the “conversation” going….but if I know you you’re already thinking about that!
October 29th, 2006 at 11:11 pm
Can I ask, as someone who wasn’t present, what was it about Scot’s presentation that ruffled feathers? It seemed pretty tame to me. Good stuff - one of the best presentations I’ve read yet on things emerging.
October 30th, 2006 at 1:43 am
thanks for this. very helpful.
October 30th, 2006 at 2:00 pm
[...] Get the PDF paper HERE. [...]
October 30th, 2006 at 5:31 pm
ScottB:
Sorry for the delayed answer; your comment got caught by my spam filter for some reason.
The “behind the scenes” answer to your question (I got this from Scot personally) was that he was a little nervous, assuming that at a conservative Reformed seminary an emergent-friendly Arminian would not be warmly recieved. Because of that, he came on a little strong in his first address. Although I didn’t feel this way, some students felt they were being scolded, which struck them as peculiar since there was so much in his talk that they could resonate with.
I think that as the three days progressed and Scot had opportunity to interact with our students, the vast majority of whom were very welcoming, he warmed up to us, as we did to him. I’m hoping that he left impressed that, whatever doctrinal difference may be there, most of us at WTS share a missional passion with him.
October 31st, 2006 at 9:55 am
[...] scot mcknight recently delivered some lectures at westminster theological sem, one specifically on “what is the emerging church?”. the transcript of the talk is available (in pdf download) from mark at sacred journey. here’s the link to the pdf. mcknight blogged about the time at wts here. [...]
October 31st, 2006 at 12:13 pm
[...] Mark Traphagen (who blogs at the foolish sage) posted the full text of Scot McKnight's definition which he gave in his first address to the Westminster Theological Seminary Student Association Forum An Eternal Word in an ‘Emerging World’? [...]
October 31st, 2006 at 3:29 pm
[...] Read the paper for yourself. Thanks to the Foolish Sage for posting the paper for download. [...]
November 4th, 2006 at 4:09 pm
[...] http://foolishsage.com/2006/10/29/scot-mcknights-full-text-of-what-is-the-emerging-church-available-here/ [...]
November 6th, 2006 at 9:32 pm
[...] Scot McKnight’s talk last weekend at Wesminster Theological Seminary is now available (PDF from Mark at Sacred Journey). You can read Scot’s post on the conference here. [...]
April 13th, 2007 at 3:50 pm
[...] for more information. Here’s an interview. Here is a detailed presentation by McKnight on “What is the emerging church?” Roger asks if I disagree with Mclaren, Driscoll, Padget and Bell overall. I have heard very [...]
April 16th, 2007 at 11:53 am
[...] I stumbled upon this great article (well, actually a transcript) by Scott McKnight, which gives the most concise summary I’ve yet [...]
August 3rd, 2007 at 1:24 pm
[...] the religiously-interested among us. I took the time to print off the thirty-page document found here titled, “What is the Emerging Church?†by Scot McKnight. It is his lecture given eight days ago [...]